Lead and Heavy Metals in Protein Powder: What the Consumer Reports and Clean Label Project Tests Found
Consumer Reports found more lead than its daily limit in over two-thirds of 23 protein products; plant-based powders averaged nine times more than dairy. Here is what the data shows and which powders measured lower.
We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission.
I’m Fred, a marketer—not a doctor or dietitian. AI helps me draft, but every factual claim below links to its primary source so you can check the evidence yourself. The direct answer: lead was found in many protein powders examined by Consumer Reports and the Clean Label Project, with plant-based products averaging more lead than dairy-based ones in both. The Clean Label Project also flagged chocolate flavors, while Consumer Reports found no meaningful chocolate-versus-vanilla difference in its sample. That does not mean every powder is dangerous or that every product within a category has the same result.
The short answer
- Consumer Reports reported in October 2025 that more than two-thirds of 23 protein powders and ready-to-drink shakes contained over 0.5 micrograms of lead per serving, the daily level it used for evaluating products.
- In that October 2025 Consumer Reports analysis, plant-based products averaged nine times as much lead as dairy-based products and twice as much as beef-based products.
- The Clean Label Project reported in January 2025 that 47% of 160 products examined during 2023–2024 exceeded at least one federal or state contaminant threshold included in its methodology; 21% exceeded twice California’s Proposition 65 lead level.
- A “Prop 65” comparison is not the same thing as an FDA safety limit. California’s reproductive-toxicity safe-harbor level for lead is 0.5 micrograms per day, while FDA dietary interim reference levels are 2.2 micrograms per day for children and 8.8 micrograms per day for females of childbearing age.
- For a lower-risk choice, favor a dairy isolate if tolerated, consider an unflavored option, and ask for a recent lot-specific laboratory report listing lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury in micrograms per serving.
What Consumer Reports found in 2025
The October 2025 Consumer Reports protein powder lead investigation covered 23 powders and prepared shakes made from plant, dairy and beef proteins. More than two-thirds delivered over 0.5 micrograms of lead in one labeled serving. Consumer Reports adopted that daily level of concern from California’s Proposition 65 reproductive-toxicity safe harbor; it is a conservative screening benchmark, not a federal protein-powder limit.
The category pattern was more useful than a permanent “protein powder lead list.” Plant-based products averaged nine times the lead measured in dairy-based products and twice the amount in beef-based products. Nearly all plant products had elevated results under Consumer Reports’ framework. However, half of the dairy products also had enough contamination for the organization to advise against daily use. “Plant-based” therefore indicates a higher average in this sample, not a guarantee about an individual powder.
Consumer Reports found that two plant-based products supplied 1,200%–1,600% of its 0.5-microgram-per-day benchmark in one serving: Naked Nutrition Vegan Mass Gainer (7.7 micrograms per 315 g, six-scoop serving, about 1,570%) and Huel Black Edition (6.3 micrograms per 90 g serving, about 1,290%). Two others supplied 400%–600%: Garden of Life Sport Organic Plant-Based Protein (564%) and Momentous 100% Plant Protein (476%; Momentous told CR it has been discontinued). Consumer Reports advised avoiding the first two and limiting the latter two to once weekly. CR also reported 9.2 micrograms of cadmium in one serving of Huel Black Edition, more than twice the 4.1-microgram daily level it uses for cadmium, and 8.5 micrograms of inorganic arsenic per serving of Optimum Nutrition Serious Mass, twice its arsenic limit. These figures describe the particular samples and serving sizes examined; they should not be generalized to every lot made under the same label.
Consumer Reports results by product
All 28 products from the two rounds, as CR published them (October 2025, January 2026), from highest to lowest result. The result is the amount in one labeled serving as a percentage of CR’s level of concern: 0.5 micrograms a day for lead and CR’s own daily limit for inorganic arsenic, which was the deciding metal only for Serious Mass. Each line describes the flavor and lots CR bought, not every flavor or future lot of the brand. CR notes that Momentous discontinued both of its products and that Vega renamed its powder and moved its pea sourcing to North America after the samples were bought.
| Product and flavor (as listed by CR) | Serving | CR result per serving | CR advice | Round |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Naked Nutrition Vegan Mass Gainer, Vanilla | 315 g powder | 1,572% (lead) | Avoid | Oct 2025 |
| Huel Black Edition, Chocolate | 90 g powder | 1,288% (lead) | Avoid | Oct 2025 |
| Garden of Life Sport Organic Plant-Based Protein, Vanilla | 45 g powder | 564% (lead) | Limit to about once a week | Oct 2025 |
| Momentous 100% Plant Protein, Chocolate (discontinued) | 37.7 g powder | 476% (lead) | Limit to about once a week | Oct 2025 |
| MuscleMeds Carnivor Mass, Chocolate Peanut Butter | 191 g powder | 247% (lead) | Occasionally: 2¾ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| Optimum Nutrition Serious Mass, Vanilla | 340 g powder | 202% (inorganic arsenic) | Occasionally: 3½ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| Jocko Fuel Mölk Protein Shake, Chocolate | 355 ml shake | 199% (lead) | Occasionally: 3½ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| Vega Premium Sport Plant-Based Protein, Chocolate (now Vega Protein + Recovery) | 44 g powder | 185% (lead) | Occasionally: 3¾ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| Quest Protein Shake, Chocolate | 325 ml shake | 161% (lead) | Occasionally: 4⅓ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Protein Shake, Chocolate | 325 ml shake | 150% (lead) | Occasionally: 4⅔ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| Equip Foods Prime Protein, Chocolate | 25.7 g powder | 144% (lead) | Occasionally: 4¾ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| Orgain Organic Plant-Based Protein Powder, Vanilla Bean | 46 g powder | 143% (lead) | Occasionally: 4¾ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| PlantFusion Complete Protein, Creamy Vanilla Bean | 30 g powder | 140% (lead) | Occasionally: 5 servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| Ensure Plant-Based Protein Nutrition Shake, Chocolate | 330 ml shake | 132% (lead) | Occasionally: 5⅓ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| Muscle Milk Pro Advanced Nutrition Protein Shake, Chocolate | 330 ml shake | 128% (lead) | Occasionally: 5½ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| KOS Organic Superfood Plant Protein, Vanilla | 37 g powder | 112% (lead) | Occasionally: 6¼ servings a week | Oct 2025 |
| Ritual Essential Protein Daily Shake, Chocolate | 33 g powder | 107% (lead) | Occasionally: 6½ servings a week | Jan 2026 |
| Truvani Plant-Based Protein, Chocolate | 33 g powder | 93% (lead) | Daily: 1 serving a day | Jan 2026 |
| Owyn Pro Elite High Protein Shake, Chocolate | 330 ml shake | 88% (lead) | Daily: 1 serving a day | Oct 2025 |
| Transparent Labs Mass Gainer, Sweet Vanilla | 194 g powder | 87% (lead) | Daily: 1 serving a day | Oct 2025 |
| Premier Protein Protein Powder, Chocolate Milkshake | 41 g powder | 77% (lead) | Daily: 1⅓ servings a day | Jan 2026 |
| Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Chocolate | 30.5 g powder | 56% (lead) | Daily: 1¾ servings a day | Oct 2025 |
| Equate Whey Protein Powder, Rich Chocolate | 30.4 g powder | 55% (lead) | Daily: 1¾ servings a day | Jan 2026 |
| BSN Syntha-6 Protein Powder, Vanilla Ice Cream | 47 g powder | 46% (lead) | Daily: 2 servings a day | Oct 2025 |
| Clean Simple Eats Protein Powder, Chocolate Brownie Batter | 34 g powder | 42% (lead) | Daily: 2⅓ servings a day | Jan 2026 |
| Momentous Whey Protein Isolate, Vanilla (discontinued) | 26.5 g powder | 30% (lead) | Daily: 3⅓ servings a day | Oct 2025 |
| Dymatize Super Mass Gainer, Gourmet Vanilla | 333 g powder | 25% (lead) | Daily: 4 servings a day | Oct 2025 |
| MuscleTech 100% Mass Gainer, Vanilla Milkshake | 357 g powder | Lead not detected | No limit | Oct 2025 |
That last qualification matters. Agricultural inputs, ingredient suppliers, harvest locations, recipes and manufacturing lots can change. A result from one container is evidence about that sample, not proof that all past and future containers have identical protein powder lead content. This is why a static list of which protein powders have lead can become misleading unless it includes the date, flavor, lot and serving size.
The report does not establish that an occasional shake will cause immediate harm. Consumer Reports framed repeated exposure as the central concern because lead can accumulate and people also encounter it through food, water and the environment. The practical response is to reduce avoidable exposure, not panic over a single serving.
In January 2026, after reader requests, Consumer Reports published lab results for five more chocolate protein powders: Clean Simple Eats, Equate, Premier Protein, Ritual and Truvani. All five were lower on average than the October sample. The three whey-based powders and Truvani’s pea-based powder came in under the 0.5-microgram level (42%–93% of it per serving), making Truvani the only plant-based powder (as opposed to a ready-to-drink shake) in either round of CR’s results to do so; Ritual’s pea-based powder was just over it at 107%. CR bought two to three lots of each product, so these results are averages across lots.

What the Clean Label Project found
The Clean Label Project’s Protein Powder Study 2.0 white paper, published in January 2025, reports results from 160 products representing 70 brands and 35,862 analytical data points collected during 2023–2024. Products came from sales data, online bestseller lists and the natural and organic market. An independent analytical laboratory used inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry, or ICP-MS, to measure arsenic, cadmium, lead and mercury.
The project reported that 47% of the 160 products exceeded at least one federal or state threshold included in its evaluation, while 21% exceeded twice California’s Proposition 65 lead level. Those percentages combine a broad product sample with the project’s chosen regulatory comparisons. They do not mean 47% violated a single nationwide protein-powder standard.
| Category or finding | Reported result | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Plant-based powders | 77% exceeded the Prop 65 lead level | A category-level result, not a claim about every plant powder |
| Whey powders | 28% exceeded the Prop 65 lead level | Lower than the plant category, but not zero |
| Collagen powders | 26% exceeded the Prop 65 lead level | Similar caution applies: formulation and lot still matter |
| Chocolate powders | 65% exceeded the Prop 65 lead level; 29% exceeded twice that level | Cocoa can add another contaminant source beyond the protein ingredient |
| Organic powders | 79% exceeded the Prop 65 lead level; 41% exceeded twice that level | Organic certification does not certify low heavy-metal content |
| All products | 47% exceeded at least one included federal or state threshold; 21% exceeded twice the Prop 65 lead level | Results span multiple contaminants and comparison standards |
The same 2023–2024 dataset found five times as much cadmium in plant-based powders as in whey-based powders, on average. Chocolate products contained 110 times as much cadmium as vanilla products, on average. These are category comparisons rather than concentrations in micrograms per serving, so they cannot tell you the dose in a particular shake. For collagen powders specifically, see collagen side effects and heavy metals.
Clean Label Project also found that organic products averaged three times as much lead as non-organic products, largely because the organic group contained more plant-based formulas. That does not show that organic farming itself causes the difference. It illustrates a confounding factor: products can belong to several overlapping categories, making simple label-based conclusions unreliable.

Why plant and chocolate powders can be higher
Heavy metals occur naturally in rock and soil, and their concentrations can also be increased by mining, industry and past pollution. Plants take up minerals from soil and water as they grow. The amount varies by crop, field, geography, soil chemistry and agricultural practices. Grinding and concentrating a plant into a protein ingredient may also concentrate contaminants already present in the raw material.
This explains the broad plant-versus-whey pattern without implying that every vegan powder is high in lead. A carefully sourced pea, rice, soy or mixed-plant ingredient can perform better than another plant ingredient grown elsewhere. Consumers comparing the best vegan protein powders should therefore look beyond “natural,” “organic” or “clean” claims and request actual laboratory numbers.
Cocoa introduces a separate issue. The Clean Label Project’s January 2025 category data associated chocolate flavor with higher lead and especially cadmium results. Consumer Reports’ October 2025 sample did not show the same lead pattern: its chocolate and vanilla products averaged 17.3 and 15.4 parts per billion of lead, which CR called no meaningful difference, although it notes that earlier tests have identified chocolate as a notable source of heavy metals. An unflavored or vanilla formula removes cocoa as one potential contributor, although vanilla flavor does not guarantee a low result. Coffee, botanicals, greens blends and added mineral ingredients can create additional sourcing variables.
Whey begins with milk rather than a crop harvested directly from soil. That likely helps explain why dairy formulas had lower category averages in both primary investigations. Processing whey into an isolate can also remove much of its lactose, fat and carbohydrate, although heavy-metal performance still depends on sourcing and manufacturing. See how protein powder is made and how to choose, or compare the practical features of a whey protein isolate and of grass-fed whey.
People who avoid dairy still have reasonable options. The goal is not to abandon plant protein but to demand better evidence: recent results for the exact formula and preferably the exact lot. A short ingredient list and no cocoa may reduce the number of possible contaminant sources. An unflavored single-source plant isolate can also make a supplier’s documentation easier to interpret.

How FDA and California benchmarks differ
The numbers in headlines are easy to misread because the FDA, California and independent organizations answer different questions.
The FDA states that no safe level of lead exposure has been identified. In 2022, it set dietary interim reference levels of 2.2 micrograms per day for children and 8.8 micrograms per day for females of childbearing age. These values include a tenfold safety factor and are exposure benchmarks, not permission for each supplement to contribute that full amount. They account for lead consumed from the total diet.
FDA’s January 2025 guidance sets action levels for certain processed foods intended for babies and children younger than two years, but it is not a protein-powder standard and is not intended to guide individual shopping decisions. FDA evaluates contamination using toxicity, measured concentration, expected consumption and vulnerability of the exposed population. It can act against unsafe food even when no product-specific action level exists.
California’s Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment lists a Proposition 65 maximum allowable dose level of 0.5 micrograms per day for lead’s reproductive effects and an oral no-significant-risk level of 15 micrograms per day for cancer, as listed in 2026. The 0.5-microgram figure determines when exposure may fall within a reproductive-toxicity warning safe harbor. It is not a dividing line where 0.49 micrograms is harmless and 0.51 micrograms is poisoning.
A Proposition 65 warning also does not reveal the measured concentration. A company may warn because it estimates exposure above a safe harbor, because it wants to limit legal risk or because ingredients vary. Conversely, the absence of a warning is not laboratory proof of a lead-free protein powder.
Protein powders to compare for lower heavy-metal exposure
The list below is deliberately short. It includes only powders that have a published Consumer Reports lead result and are sold on iHerb US, so every lead figure comes from CR’s own lab data rather than a brand claim. Lead figures are CR’s per-serving results as a percentage of its 0.5-microgram daily level of concern, for the flavor CR bought; other flavors and later lots were not part of CR’s results. Prices and labels were read on iHerb US on 22 November 2026; price per 25 g of protein = price / (servings x protein per serving) x 25. The iHerb page is the final word on price.
| Powder | Protein | CR lead per serving (% of 0.5 mcg/day) | CR verdict | Protein per serving | Price per 25 g protein | Certification |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BSN Syntha-6 Ultra Premium Protein Matrix, Vanilla Ice Cream | Whey/casein/milk protein blend | 46% | Better choice for daily consumption | 22 g | $1.83 | none found |
| Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Double Rich Chocolate | Whey blend | 56% | Better choice for daily consumption | 24 g | $1.62 | NSF Certified for Sport, Informed Choice |
| Premier Protein 100% Whey Protein Powder, Chocolate Milkshake | Whey isolate + concentrate | 77% | Better choice for daily consumption | 30 g | $2.51 | none found |
| Ritual Essential Protein Daily Shake, Chocolate | Organic pea protein | 107% | Okay to eat occasionally | 20 g | $4.08 | Clean Label Project Certified |
Two caveats. First, CR’s mass gainers and ready-to-drink shakes are left out: they are different products, and the shakes are not powders. Second, no plant-based powder in CR’s October sample came in under its level of concern; the only plant powder that did, Truvani in the January follow-up, is not sold on iHerb, so Ritual is the closest available plant option and it sits just above the line.
BSN Syntha-6 Ultra Premium Protein Matrix, Vanilla Ice Cream
CR bought the Vanilla Ice Cream flavor, the one linked here, and measured 46% of its lead level per 47 g serving, the lowest of the powders on this list; CR’s limit for it is two servings a day. It is a blend of whey, casein and milk proteins with 22 g of protein, 5 g of fat and 15 g of carbohydrate (6 g of fiber) per serving, so it is closer to a meal-style shake than an isolate. No certifier listing found. Regular one-time iHerb US price $77.16 for 48 servings, which works out to $1.83 per 25 g of protein. See it on iHerb
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Double Rich Chocolate
CR measured 56% of its lead level per 30.5 g serving of a chocolate flavor and set a limit of one and three-quarter servings a day. This tub is Double Rich Chocolate: 24 g of protein from a whey isolate, concentrate and hydrolysate blend, with cocoa and acesulfame potassium. Gold Standard 100% Whey is listed in both the NSF Certified for Sport list and the Informed Choice database. The lowest price per 25 g of protein here. Regular one-time iHerb US price $114.99 for 74 servings, which works out to $1.62 per 25 g of protein. See it on iHerb
Premier Protein 100% Whey Protein Powder, Chocolate Milkshake
CR’s January 2026 follow-up measured 0.38 micrograms of lead per 41 g serving of Chocolate Milkshake, 77% of its level, with a limit of one and one-third servings a day. 30 g of protein from whey isolate and concentrate, 1 g of sugars, sweetened with acesulfame potassium and sucralose. No certifier listing found. Regular one-time iHerb US price $51.25 for 17 servings, which works out to $2.51 per 25 g of protein. See it on iHerb
Ritual Essential Protein Daily Shake, Chocolate
The only plant-based powder on this list: organic pea protein, 20 g per 33 g serving, sweetened with monk fruit. CR measured 0.53 micrograms of lead per serving of the chocolate flavor, 107% of its level, and rated it fine for up to six and a half servings a week rather than daily. The iHerb page carries a California Proposition 65 lead warning. Ritual is Clean Label Project Certified; it is also the most expensive per 25 g of protein here. Regular one-time iHerb US price $48.99 for 15 servings, which works out to $4.08 per 25 g of protein. See it on iHerb
How to choose a lower-risk powder
“Lead free protein powder” is usually too absolute. Laboratory instruments have detection limits, results vary between lots, and “not detected” means below that method’s reporting threshold—not proof that no lead atom is present. “Lower measured lead in this lot” is a more defensible target.
- Ask for lot-specific results. Request a certificate of analysis for the lot number you plan to buy. It should name an independent laboratory, analysis date, sample identifier, method and reporting limit.
- Require useful units. Micrograms per serving are easiest for comparing daily exposure. If a report gives parts per billion, concentration alone is insufficient; serving weight is needed to calculate dose.
- Check all four metals. A report that mentions only lead cannot establish that arsenic, cadmium and mercury are low.
- Prefer simpler formulas. An unflavored isolate avoids cocoa and reduces the number of agricultural ingredients. This is a risk-reduction heuristic, not a guarantee.
- Use certification correctly. NSF Certified for Sport and Informed Sport are valuable for identity, quality systems and banned-substance controls, but consumers should verify what contaminant limits a certification applies to. Clean Label Project certification is more directly focused on contaminants, although the scope and lot coverage still deserve scrutiny.
- Compare realistic consumption. Multiply the laboratory result per serving by the number of servings used. Do not compare one product’s per-scoop figure with another product’s per-day figure.
- Recheck periodically. A supplier, recipe or harvest can change. A report several years old may not represent a current lot.
Label quality still matters after contaminant screening. Compare protein per serving, ingredients, sweeteners and lactose, then normalize value by calculating cost per 25 grams of protein. People sensitive to lactose can consult the guide to lactose-free protein powder. None of these label features substitutes for a heavy-metal report.
Who should choose which option?
For dairy-tolerant adults prioritizing lower average heavy-metal exposure: an unflavored whey isolate with recent lot-specific results is a sensible starting point. The 2025 Consumer Reports and Clean Label Project category findings both favored dairy over plant formulas on average.
For vegans or people avoiding milk: consider an unflavored single-source plant isolate backed by a current certificate reporting micrograms per serving. Do not assume that “organic” means lower lead. A guide to pea protein powder can help with nutrition and texture considerations, but contaminant documentation must be assessed separately.
For people who strongly prefer chocolate: look for direct lead and cadmium results for that chocolate formula. Results from an unflavored or vanilla version do not establish the chocolate version’s content.
For occasional users: frequency matters. Using a powder less often reduces the exposure contributed by that product. Whole foods such as dairy, eggs, soy foods, beans, fish, poultry, nuts and seeds may make a powder unnecessary, depending on dietary needs.
For athletes subject to drug screening: start with NSF Certified for Sport or Informed Sport, then separately check the heavy-metal data. Banned-substance screening and low lead are related quality questions, but they are not interchangeable.
For pregnant people, children or anyone with kidney disease: ask a doctor before using a concentrated supplement. These groups may need individualized advice about protein intake, minerals and contaminant exposure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does all protein powder contain lead?
No. Lead may be absent at an analytical method’s reporting limit, present in trace amounts or present at a higher concentration. Consumer Reports found detectable contamination across much of its October 2025 sample, but results varied substantially. “Not detected” is more accurate than “lead free” unless the claim defines the method and detection limit.
Which protein powders have lead?
A reliable lead-in-protein-powder list must identify the precise formula, flavor, lot, analysis date, serving size and laboratory method. Brand-level lists can mislead because lots and recipes change. Use the October 2025 and January 2026 Consumer Reports results and the January 2025 Clean Label Project findings as snapshots, then request current lot-specific documentation before buying.
What is the best protein powder without heavy metals?
No protein source can be guaranteed completely free of heavy metals. Based on the 2025 category data, an unflavored dairy isolate with a recent independent report showing low lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury per serving is a reasonable lower-risk choice for someone who tolerates dairy. The best vegan protein powder without heavy metals would similarly be an unflavored plant isolate supported by current lot data—not merely an organic or “clean” claim.
Should I stop using protein powder because lead was found?
Not necessarily. Consider your product’s actual result, how often you use it and whether you need a supplement at all. Choosing a documented lower-contaminant formula, avoiding unnecessary daily servings and using protein-rich foods more often can reduce exposure. If you are pregnant, buying for a child or living with kidney disease, ask a doctor for individualized advice.